Expression Blend: Template loops (no problems in Cider, though)

.NET, Blend, Technical stuff, WPF
See comments

In one of my side-projects, I wanted to create a kind of lightweight treeview, as simple as possible: An item can contain a list of items; each item is simple represented by a string. In OO design, it’s rather easy: You crate a DataItem class, which contains a Description and a collection of DataItems (children).

Wanting to take advantage of ControlTemplates and DataTemplates, I thought I would create the following structure in WPF:

- Window
    – Grid
        – Control
            – Template “MyControlTemplate” (ControlTemplate)
                – TextBlock “Description”
                – ItemsControl
                    – ItemTemplate “MyDataTemplate” (DataTemplate)
                        – Control
                            – ControlTemplate “MyControlTemplate”

Note that there is no infinite recursion: I have a finite number of items; if the collection of children is empty, no DataTemplate should be instantiated.

In order to make the design easier, and as I use to do nowadays in WPF, I use the Model-ViewModel-View pattern which I described (with other names, but still) here. I then found out that strangely enough, Expression Blend is unable to display the structure, even though Cider (in Orcas September CTP) doesn’t have any problems with it.

I submitted this case to the Blend team. I met them last time I was in Redmond, and they’re great guys, who do listen to their customers!

A test project where this problem can be visualized is available on my site.

TemplateLoop in Cider (successful)
TemplateLoop in Cider (successful)
 
TemplateLoop in Blend (fail)
TemplateLoop in Blend (fail)
 
Previous entry | Next blog entry

Comments for Expression Blend: Template loops (no problems in Cider, though)